← All articles

Pothole Damage Compensation: How to Claim from the Council

Matthew Croxford
By · · Updated
Short answer:

Yes, you can claim pothole damage compensation from your council in 2026, but you must show it knew or should have known about the defect and failed to fix it in time. Report the pothole, keep evidence and photos, then submit a claim under the Highways Act 1980 - most are rejected first time, so be ready to push back.

Hit a pothole hard enough and you'll know about it straight away: a thud through the steering wheel, a shudder, maybe a tyre losing air on the way home. The repair bill for a bent alloy, a split tyre or a knocked-out tracking setup can run into hundreds of pounds, and plenty of drivers don't realise they can ask the council to pay for it. The trouble is that councils reject the majority of claims, and they do so using a perfectly legal defence built into the same law that creates their duty to maintain the road in the first place.

Can you actually claim compensation for pothole damage in 2026?

Yes. If a pothole on a public road damages your car, you can submit a claim to the highway authority responsible for that stretch of road, usually your local council, or National Highways on motorways and most trunk A-roads. The right to claim hasn't changed and isn't new for 2026; it's been part of English and Welsh law for decades. What has changed is the scale of the problem: with road surfaces under growing pressure, more drivers than ever are submitting claims, and more councils are getting better at fighting them off.

What's the legal basis for a pothole compensation claim?

Two sections of the same Act do all the work here.

The council's duty to maintain the highway

Section 41 of the Highways Act 1980 places a duty on the highway authority to maintain a highway that's maintainable at public expense, which covers the vast majority of UK roads. If the council has failed in that duty and your car was damaged as a direct result, you have the basis for a claim.

The council's statutory defence

Section 58 of the same Act then hands the council an escape route. As the legislation itself puts it, it is a defence for the authority to prove that the authority had taken such care as in all the circumstances was reasonably required to keep that part of the highway safe for traffic. In plain English: if the council can show it had a sensible inspection and repair regime running, and the pothole either hadn't been reported or had only just appeared since the last inspection, it can walk away from your claim without paying a penny. This is why so many claims get turned down with a standard letter quoting 'Section 58' and nothing else.

How do you actually make a claim, step by step?

The process is fairly mechanical, but skipping a step gives the council an easy reason to say no.

1. Report the pothole straight away

Report the defect to the council (or via the national report a pothole service, which forwards your report to the right authority) as soon as possible after the incident, even if you've already had the repair done. This creates an official record and, if the pothole causes someone else damage later, helps establish the council knew about it.

2. Gather your evidence before it disappears

  • Photos of the pothole itself, with something for scale (a coin, a tape measure, your shoe)
  • The exact location - the road name, nearest junction or postcode, and ideally what3words
  • Date, time and weather conditions
  • Photos of the damage to your car
  • An itemised, dated invoice or two independent repair quotes
  • Dashcam footage of the impact, if you have it

3. Submit the claim form

Most councils have an online 'claim for vehicle damage' form, separate from the pothole reporting tool. Fill it in fully, attach your evidence, and keep a copy of everything you send. Councils generally pass the claim to their insurer or risk management team, so expect it to take several weeks for a decision.

How likely is your claim to succeed?

Lower than you'd hope, in most cases. Figures published by Lincolnshire County Council under a Freedom of Information request give a realistic picture: in 2024/25 the council received 1,014 pothole damage claims, settled 158 of them, and repudiated 823, paying out just over £34,000 in total that year, with its single highest payout on record reaching £16,200. That pattern, a large number of claims submitted and only a minority settled, tends to repeat across councils. It doesn't mean claiming is pointless; it means a well-evidenced claim stands a noticeably better chance than a vague one.

Every council publishes its own claims data differently and the figures move year to year, so treat the Lincolnshire example as illustrative rather than a national average. If you want your own council's current numbers, submit a Freedom of Information request or check its website directly.

What happens if your claim is rejected?

A rejection letter citing Section 58 isn't necessarily the end of the road.

  • Ask for the inspection records. You're entitled to request the council's inspection history for that stretch of road via a Freedom of Information request. If the pothole had been reported before your incident, or the road was overdue an inspection under the council's own schedule, the Section 58 defence starts to look shaky.
  • Query the defence directly. Write back challenging the specific grounds given, rather than accepting a generic refusal at face value.
  • Consider the small claims track. For amounts under £10,000, you can take the matter to the small claims court without needing a solicitor, though you'll want solid evidence before you do.
  • Don't sit on it. The law only gives you a limited window to bring a formal claim, so chase a decision promptly rather than letting months slide by.

What can you claim for, and what's off the table?

Typical successful claims cover tyres, alloy wheels, suspension components, wheel tracking and alignment, and sometimes exhaust or bodywork damage where the impact was severe enough. You'll generally need to show the damage is consistent with a pothole strike rather than general wear, which is where independent garage reports help. Claims for the pothole simply being an inconvenience, or for a car that was already due new tyres anyway, won't get far.

If a hard pothole hit has knocked your tracking out or cracked an alloy, it's worth checking the car over properly rather than just living with a pull to one side. Our free reg lookup pulls up the car's full MOT history, including any advisories that might flag developing suspension or steering issues, its DVLA details, any outstanding safety recalls, and a free market valuation, all from the number plate.

Does pothole damage affect what the car is worth, or what you should check before buying one?

A single pothole claim rarely dents a car's resale value once it's properly repaired, but repeated suspension or alignment issues can shorten the life of tyres and bushings, which is worth factoring in if you're thinking of selling. If you're on the other side of the transaction and buying a used car, it's sensible to look past the obvious and check its background properly. Our vehicle history check, with data provided by Experian, shows whether a car has outstanding finance, has been recorded as an insurance write-off or stolen, how many previous keepers it's had, and whether it's been imported, exported or scrapped, useful context if a car's had a hard life on rough roads.

The blog continues below. Tap to skip ahead ↓
Check any UK reg free
MotifyMe offers a free MOT, tax and valuation check on any UK reg, a full vehicle history check, with data provided by Experian, finance introductions, a marketplace to buy and sell cars and free fuel and running-cost tools.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to report a pothole before I can claim for damage? You don't strictly have to, but reporting it promptly, even after you've had the repair done, creates an official record of the defect and strengthens your position if the council later disputes when it first became aware of the problem.

Which council do I claim against? The highway authority responsible for the road, which is usually your local council for most A, B and minor roads, or National Highways for motorways and most trunk A-roads in England.

What if the council rejects my claim using Section 58? Ask for its inspection records for that road via a Freedom of Information request, challenge the specific grounds given, and consider the small claims court for amounts under £10,000 if you still believe the claim is justified.

Can I claim for a tyre blowout from a pothole? Yes, provided you can show the damage was caused by a specific pothole and not general wear, supported by an itemised invoice or independent garage report describing the damage.

Will a pothole claim show up when I sell the car? A repaired pothole claim itself isn't recorded against the vehicle, but any resulting MOT advisories or failures will appear in its MOT history, which a buyer can check using a free reg lookup.

Thinking of buying or selling a used car? Check any UK reg free, with no sign-up.

You get MOT history, tax status and key details in seconds. For outstanding finance, write-off and stolen checks, our paid vehicle history check is available, with data provided by Experian.

Check a reg free → Browse used cars from UK dealers →

How we write and correct our articles: editorial policy.